Skip to content

New K-12 science curriculum scrutinized; December vote by Board of Ed expected

Reported byWLRNBy Jay WaagmeesterJay Waagmeester's page at the publisher (opens in a new tab)

Discuss
The Turlington Building, which houses the Florida Department of Education, stands in the foreground, with the Tallahassee skyline, including the Capitol building, beyond. Photo taken from the FAMU campus on Dec. 31, 2024.
Image: WLRNReport a problem with this photo
Read at WLRN (opens in a new tab)

AI-assisted preview

Florida Education Commissioner Henry Mack used a Board of Education meeting to defend the department's rewrite of the state's K-12 science standards, which have not been updated since 2008. The proposed standards are in a public review period, and the department has held discussions in Walton County, Hillsborough County and online on Sept. 30. The article says the state board is expected to vote on the standards in December.

Mack said the aim is clear, rigorous standards rooted in the scientific method and free of ideology. He also said he wants to avoid "scientism" and the notion that science is always settled. He rejected claims that evolution or climate science is being removed, saying both appear in the standards, including sea level rise. He invited the public to a listening session on Oct. 27 from 5:30 to 7:30 p.m. at Lake Buena Vista High School in Orange County.

Critics have objected. The National Center for Science Education opposes the proposal, and its deputy director said it falls short on climate change and evolution and leans on trivia over depth. According to a Sentinel report, many commenters at an earlier event called the standards vague on those topics. The Florida Education Association said the revision should follow research and evidence, and argued that a document of over 1,000 pages needs more review time and additional virtual town halls. Board member Grazie Pozo Christie voiced support for Mack's approach.

Why it matters

State science standards shape what students are taught in classrooms across Florida. Families and educators have a limited window to comment before the expected December vote, and critics and the department disagree about how the standards treat climate change and evolution.

  • State Board of Education
  • Instructional materials
  • Public comment
  • Religion in schools

A short preview written with AI from the publisher's article. It may contain errors; the full story has the details and is the authoritative source. Our editorial standards.

Read the full story at WLRN (opens in a new tab)
Discuss

Questions to discuss

  • How much time and what formats should the public get to review a science standards document of more than 1,000 pages?
  • How can state officials and educators balance keeping standards free of ideology with ensuring evolution and climate science are covered in depth?
  • What would help parents and teachers judge whether proposed standards are clear and rigorous enough?

Suggested with AI.

Public discussion

Share how this affects your community. Be respectful, stay on topic, and don't post personal information. Editors may hide comments that break these rules.